Supreme Court case information
Listed below are the substantive Supreme Court cases for the year along with appeals still to be determined or cases awaiting hearing.
Information giving an overview of the case is included along with media releases and links to judgments being appealed when available.
All 2024 - 2014 Supreme Court cases dismissed or deemed to be dismissed where a notice of abandonment was received can be found here.
Transcripts for cases heard before the Supreme Court are included provided they are not suppressed. Transcripts from pre-trial hearings are not published until the final disposition of trial. These are unedited transcripts and they are not a formal record of the Court’s proceedings. The Ministry of Justice does not accept responsibility for the accuracy or completeness of any material and recommends that users exercise their own skill and care with respect to its use.
8 November 2024
Case information summary 2024 (as at 8 November 2024) – Cases where leave granted (126 KB)
Case information summary 2024 (as at 8 November 2024) – Cases where leave to appeal decision not yet made (PDF, 116 KB)
All years
Case name
Brian Johnson Mankelow v The Queen
Case number
SC 30/2007
Summary
Criminal – appeal against conviction – trial directions as to inferences – whether the Court of Appeal should have reconsidered its decision in 2005 that certain evidence was admissible in light of the decision of the Court of Appeal in R v Williams [2007] NZCA 52 – whether there has been a substantial miscarriage of justice. CA 443/06 19 April 2007
Result
Application for leave to appeal dismissed.
20 July 2007
20 July 2007
Leave judgment - leave dismissed
MANKELOW v R SC 30/2007 [20 July 2007] (PDF, 15 KB)
Judgment appealed from
Case name
Dollars and Sense Finance Limited v Rerekohu Nathan
Case number
SC 31/2007
Summary
Summary Civil appeal – enforceability of a registered mortgage – borrower forged the signature of one of the sureties, his mother, on the mortgage documents – lender’s solicitor had delivered the mortgage documents to the borrower to procure the signatures and express informed consent of the sureties – whether the borrower was the agent of the lender – whether the borrower’s fraud can be attributed to the lender – whether the surety has an in personam claim against the lender. CA 107/05 4 May 2007
Result
Application for leave to appeal granted.
29 June 2007
______________________
Appeal dismissed with costs of $15,000 and reasonable disbursements to the respondent.
8 April 2008
29 June 2007
______________________
Appeal dismissed with costs of $15,000 and reasonable disbursements to the respondent.
8 April 2008
Leave judgment - leave granted
Judgment appealed from
Transcript
Substantive judgment / Media release
Case name
Kem Raju Samy v The Queen
Case number
SC 32/2007
Summary
Criminal appeal – Appeal against conviction - whether the Court of Appeal dismissed the appellant’s appeal without allowing him to be properly heard – whether the appellant should have been permitted to return to New Zealand for the Court of Appeal hearing of his appeal against conviction - whether an adjournment should have been given to allow the appellant to be located and cross-examined via video-conference. CA 123/05 23 April 2007
Leave judgment - leave dismissed
SAMY v R SC 32/2007 [5 December 2007] (PDF, 19 KB)
Judgment appealed from
Case name
Joseph Ronald Belcher v The Chief Executive of the Department of Corrections
Case number
SC 33/2007
Summary
Criminal – sexual offending – appeal against sentence – applicant first sentenced in 1996 – Extended Supervision Order (ESO) imposed in 2005 – whether applicant received a fair hearing by an independent tribunal – whether imposition of ESO was unlawful, arbitrary and manifestly excessive – whether process by which ESO was imposed was flawed in relation to admissibility and treatment of evidence or otherwise – whether Court of Appeal erred in holding it had no jurisdiction to make a declaration of inconsistency of the Parole (Extended Supervision) Amendment Act 2004 with the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.CA 185/05 3 May 2007
Result
Application for leave to appeal dismissed.
16 July 2007
16 July 2007
Leave judgment - leave dismissed
Case name
Raymond Fraser Kara v The Queen
Case number
SC 34/2007
Summary
Summary Criminal – appeal against increase in sentence as result of successful Solicitor-General’s appeal – Court of Appeal took premeditation into account as additional aggravating factor – whether Court of Appeal formed mistaken understanding of facts of offending. CA 416/06 11 May 2007
Result
Application for leave to appeal is dismissed.
23 July 2007
23 July 2007
Leave judgment - leave dismissed
KARA v R SC 34/2007 [23 July 2007] (PDF, 16 KB)
Judgment appealed from
Case name
Philip David Sturm v The Queen
Case number
SC 35/2007
Summary
Criminal – appeal against conviction – in relation to appellant’ s conviction for stupefying with intent to facilitate the commission of a crime Court of Appeal held that Crown had to prove not only an intention to facilitate the commission of a crime but also an intention to stupefy – trial directions – whether Court of Appeal erred in finding that trial Judge’s directions were sufficient regarding the intention to stupefy – whether Court of Appeal should have focused on whether directions contained an error of law giving rise to a substantial miscarriage of justice rather than focusing on sufficiency of directions – whether Court of Appeal erred in holding that even if directions were unsatisfactory the appellant was clearly subjectively reckless – whether Court of Appeal erred in finding no error in trial Judge’s direction that the voluntary consumption of drugs and alcohol was irrelevant to stupefying counts – whether Court of Appeal erred in concluding that there was no merit in the suggestion that the verdict on the stupefying count “coloured” the other verdicts.CA 35/2007 4 May 2007
Result
Application for leave to appeal dismissed.
2 August 2007
2 August 2007
Leave judgment - leave dismissed
STURM V R SC 35/2007 [2 August 2007] (PDF, 17 KB)
Judgment appealed from
Case name
Palmiro McDonald v The Queen
Case number
SC 36/2007
Summary
Criminal appeal – Crimes Act 1961, s 339 – exercise of discretion by trial judge to include an lesser charge – whether jury direction effective to cure any prejudice caused by disclosure of inadmissible evidence at trial. CA 356/06 20 April 2007
Result
Application for leave to appeal dismissed.
21 August 2007
21 August 2007
Leave judgment - leave dismissed
McDONALD v R SC 36/2007 [21 August 2007] (PDF, 22 KB)
Judgment appealed from
Case name
Harvey Douglas White v Auckland District Health Board
Case number
SC 37/2007
Summary
Civil Appeal – leap frog appeal against decision of the Employment Court after the Court of Appeal declined leave to appeal - whether the Employment Court erred in law when it declined to grant a permanent non-publication order in relation to the applicant’s name – whether the Court considered matters for which there was no evidential basis and failed to consider relevant matters – whether the Court erred when it concluded that the applicant had brought the public consequences upon himself – whether the Court failed to ensure that it had up to date information AC 10/7 ARC 52/05 23 February 2007
Result
Application for leave to appeal dismissed. Order preventing publication of the applicants name is lifted. Costs to respondent $2,5000 plus disbursements.
8 August 2007
8 August 2007
Leave judgment - leave dismissed
Case name
Gregory Nielsen and Roderick William Nielsen v Dysart Timbers Limited
Case number
SC 38/2007
Summary
Civil appeal – interpretation of clause in deed of purchase of debt – whether deed extended to companies or entities other than those expressly mentioned in the deed.CA 253/05 22 May 2007
Result
Application for leave to appeal granted.
9 August 2007
_________________________
Notice of abandonment being lodged, the appeal is deemed to be dismissed.
3 June 2009
9 August 2007
_________________________
Notice of abandonment being lodged, the appeal is deemed to be dismissed.
3 June 2009
Leave judgment - leave granted
Judgment appealed from
Number
SC38/2007
Case name
Gustav & Co Limited v MacField Limited
Case number
SC 39/2007
Summary
Civil appeal – unconscionable bargain – contract for sale of commercial land – sole director of applicant company had a terminal illness – contract cancelled by respondent company when full deposit not paid – applicant company sought to recover partial deposit on the basis of unconscionable dealing due to director’s illness – whether the Court of Appeal erred in finding there was no duty to inquire – the extent of knowledge required for such a duty.CA 168/05 24 May 2007
Result
Application for leave to appeal granted.
4 September 2007
4 September 2007
Date of hearing
11 March 2008
Transcripts
- Hearing date 11 March 2008 (PDF, 235 KB)
Media Releases
- mediarelease gustav (PDF, 88 KB)
Court of Appeal decision
Leave judgment - leave granted
Substantive judgment
Page 222 of 250