BFSL 32007 Limited and others  v Peter David Steigrad - SC 19/2013

Summary

Civil Appeal – Law Reform Act 1936, s 9 – Charge on insurance monies in favour of third parties paid to indemnify an insured in respect of insured’s liability to third party – Priority between a s 9 charge in favour of third party claimants and an uncharged claim to defence costs by directors of a company – Whether Court of Appeal erred in holding that a s 9 charge only attaches to the balance of the insurance money available to meet third party claims after any defence cost liability has been met – Whether question of priorities under s 9 is subject to contract of insurance.[2012] NZCA 604  CA 674/2011

Result

Leave to appeal is granted.
The approved ground is: 
Did the Court of Appeal interpret s 9 of the Law Reform Act 1936 correctly?

 

15 April 2013

________________

The appeal is allowed.

The respondent is to pay costs of $25,000 to the appellants in SC 19/2013 plus usual disbursements (to be set by the Registrar, if necessary). We certify for two counsel.

23 December 2013

Additional Information

Hearing date : 17 October 2013

Elias CJ, McGrath, Glazebrook, Gault, Anderson JJ.